[Federal Register Volume 80, Number 75 (Monday, April 20, 2015)]
[Rules and Regulations]
[Pages 21654-21656]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 2015-08974]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
LEGAL SERVICES CORPORATION
45 CFR Part 1640
Application of Federal Law to LSC Recipients
AGENCY: Legal Services Corporation
ACTION: Final rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This final rule updates the Legal Services Corporation (LSC or
Corporation) regulation on the application of Federal law to LSC
recipients. The FY 1996 appropriations act (incorporated in LSC's
appropriations by reference annually thereafter) subjects LSC
recipients and its employees and board members to Federal law relating
to the proper use of Federal funds. This final rule provides recipients
with notice of the applicable Federal laws each recipient and its
employees and board members must agree to be subject to under this
rule, the consequences of a violation of an applicable Federal law, and
where LSC will maintain the list of applicable laws.
DATES: This final rule will be effective on May 20, 2015.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Stefanie K. Davis, Assistant General
Counsel, Legal Services Corporation, 3333 K Street NW., Washington, DC
20007; (202) 295-1563 (phone), (202) 337-6519 (fax), or [email protected].
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. History of This Rulemaking
Section 504(a)(19) of LSC's FY 1996 appropriations act required LSC
recipients to enter into a contract that subjected them to ``all
provisions of Federal law relating to the proper use of Federal
funds.'' Sec. 504(a)(19), Public Law.= 104-134, title V; 110 Stat.
1321. By its terms, a violation of Sec. 504(a)(19) renders any LSC
grant or contract null and void. The provision has been incorporated by
reference into each of LSC's annual appropriations act since.
Accordingly, the preamble and text of this final rule continue to refer
to the relevant section number of the FY 1996 appropriations act.
The Corporation first issued 45 CFR part 1640 as an interim rule in
1996 to implement Sec. 504(a)(19). 61 FR 45760, Aug. 29, 1996. The
interim rule was put in place to provide immediate guidance to LSC
recipients on legislation that was already in effect and carried
significant penalties for noncompliance. Id. In the preamble to the
interim rule, LSC announced that it was interpreting the statutory
phrase ``all provisions of Federal law relating to the proper use of
Federal funds'' to mean ``with respect to [a recipient's] LSC funds,
all programs should be subject to Federal laws which address issues of
waste, fraud and abuse of Federal funds.'' Id. LSC based its
interpretation on legislative history that appeared to limit the
applicable laws to those dealing with fraud, waste, and abuse of
Federal funds.
In particular, LSC relied on two congressional documents to support
its interpretation. First, the Corporation cited to the House Report
for H.R. 2076, which was a prior effort to enact a provision similar to
section 504(a)(19). The relevant language in that report stated:
[S]ection 504(20) requires all programs receiving Federal funds to
comply with Federal statutes and regulations governing waste, fraud,
and abuse of Federal funds.
H. Rep. No. 104-196, 104th Cong., 1st Sess. 116 (July 1995) (emphasis
added). Second, LSC cited section 5 of H.R. 1806, the Legal Services
Reform Act of 1995, which was an unsuccessful attempt to revise the LSC
Act. As an extension of his remarks introducing H.R. 1806, Rep.
McCollum submitted a partial summary of the bill, including a
discussion of section 5 entitled ``Application of waste, fraud, and
abuse laws.'' 141 Cong. Rec. E1220-21 (daily ed. June 9, 1995). Section
5 itself was titled ``Protection Against Theft and Fraud,'' and
expressly included provisions of Title 18 of the U.S. Code pertaining
to criminal offenses involving the misuse of Federal funds, as well as
provisions of the False Claims Act. H.R. 1806, 104th Cong., Sec. 5
(1995).
LSC adopted the list of statutes in section 5, with one exception.
Through negotiation with LSC's Office of Inspector General (OIG), LSC
determined that two other criminal statutes should be included in the
list. 61 FR 45760, Aug. 29, 1996. These statutes prohibit bribery of
public officials and witnesses and conspiracy to defraud the United
States. Id. at 45761.
Minor changes to the interim rule, not affecting this list, were
made before the
[[Page 21655]]
final rule was published in 1997. 62 FR 19424-19427, Apr. 21, 1997. LSC
has not revised Part 1640 since the publication of the final rule.
Since the final rule was published, Congress has amended or passed
other Federal laws relating to the proper use of Federal funds. In
2014, OIG raised concerns that the Sec. 1640.2(a)(1) list of
applicable Federal laws is now under-inclusive. As an example, OIG
noted the omission of 18 U.S.C. 666, which prohibits theft or bribery
concerning programs receiving Federal funds and has been the basis for
OIG's referrals to the Department of Justice for prosecution.
Subsequently, LSC staff researched other Federal laws applicable to
fraud, waste, and abuse of Federal funds. The search revealed at least
two other Federal laws relating to the proper use of Federal funds
currently missing from the Sec. 1640.2(a)(1) list: 18 U.S.C. 285--
Taking or using papers relating to claims, and 18 U.S.C. 1031--Major
fraud against the United States.
As required by the LSC Rulemaking Protocol, LSC staff prepared an
explanatory rulemaking options paper, accompanied by a proposed rule
amending Part 1640. On January 22, 2015, the Operations and Regulations
Committee (Committee) voted to authorize LSC to initiate rulemaking and
to recommend that the LSC Board of Directors (Board) approve publishing
the proposed rule. On January 24, 2015, the Board approved the proposed
rule for publication in the Federal Register for notice and comment.
LSC published the notice of the proposed rulemaking (the NPRM) in the
Federal Register on February 3, 2015. 80 FR 5016, Feb. 3, 2015. The
comment period remained open for thirty days and closed on March 5,
2015.
On April 12, 2015, the Committee considered the draft final rule
for publication and voted to recommend its publication to the Board,
subject to one amendment. The Committee voted to amend the language in
Sec. 1640.2(a) to explicitly state that the Board would vote at a
public meeting on any proposed changes to the list of Federal laws
relating to the proper use of Federal funds. The Committee made this
amendment in response to a comment made during the meeting by the
National Legal Aid and Defender Association (NLADA) expressing its
position that proposed changes to the list should be subject to public
comment prior to adoption by the Board. On April 14, 2015, the Board
voted to adopt and publish the final rule as amended.
Material regarding this rulemaking is available in the open
rulemaking section of LSC's Web site at http://www.lsc.gov/about/regulations-rules/open-rulemaking. After the effective date of the
rule, those materials will appear in the closed rulemaking section at
http://www.lsc.gov/about/regulations-rules/closed-rulemaking.
II. Section-by-Section Discussion of Comments and Regulatory Provisions
LSC received two comments during the public comment period. One
comment was submitted by an LSC-funded recipient, Colorado Legal
Services (CLS). The other comment was submitted by the non-LSC-funded
non-profit NLADA through its Civil Policy Group and its Regulations and
Policy Committee. Both commenters were generally supportive of the
changes LSC proposed to Part 1640.
Proposed Sec. 1640.1--Purpose
LSC proposed revising this section to reflect the changes to Part
1640, specifically removing the language stating that the applicable
Federal laws were identified in Part 1640. LSC received no comments on
this proposal.
Proposed Sec. 1640.2--Applicable Federal Laws
LSC proposed deleting the existing Sec. 1640.2(a)(1) list of
applicable Federal laws. The contracts between the Corporation and its
recipients, currently referred to as the LSC Grant Assurances, will be
modified to provide recipients with a weblink to the updated list. LSC
proposed a new Sec. 1640.2(a), which states that the Corporation will
maintain a public list of applicable Federal law on the Corporation's
Web site. LSC stated in the preamble of the NPRM that the list would be
exhaustive but did not specifically use that term in the proposed rule
text.
Comment 1: NLADA and CLS both expressed concern that LSC's decision
to move the list of applicable Federal laws from the rule to LSC's Web
site would decrease stakeholders' ability to comment on proposed
changes to the list. NLADA noted that this was the second proposal by
LSC in the past year to remove a section of a regulation from the usual
rulemaking process. NLADA stated: ``While we understand and support
LSC's desire in this instance to avoid an unnecessary, time-consuming
regulatory process, we want to confirm NLADA's very strong support''
for LSC's commitment, expressed in the 2002 rulemaking protocol, to
``conduct its rulemaking activities in a spirit of cooperative dialog
with [] recipients and other interested parties.'' CLS similarly
asserted that ``[a]s LSC is a program uniquely committed to protecting
due process rights and protections, it should adhere to them strictly
itself and provide an opportunity for comment before the list of
Federal laws relating to the proper use of Federal funds by LSC
recipients is modified or changed.''
Response: LSC views updating the list of applicable Federal laws to
be an administrative task that does not affect the underlying substance
of the rule. Updating the list does not materially change the Part 1640
requirement that recipients, and its employees and board members,
comply with Federal laws relating to the proper use of Federal funds.
Although the regulation does not require notice and an opportunity
for comment before submitting modifications of the list to the Board
for approval, LSC remains committed to providing recipients with notice
of any proposed modifications before a Board meeting. Recipients will
have an opportunity to comment on the proposed modifications prior to
and at the meeting where the modifications will be discussed.
Comment 2: CLS and NLADA supported LSC's decision to make the list
of applicable Federal laws exhaustive. In its comment, NLADA
recommended that LSC include language in the text of the rule stating
that the list is exhaustive.
Response: LSC will adopt NLADA's recommendation. LSC will revise
the first sentence of Sec. 1640.2(a) to read: ``LSC will maintain an
exhaustive list of applicable Federal laws relating to the proper use
of Federal funds on its Web site and provide recipients with a link to
the list in the contractual agreement.''
LSC proposed renumbering Sec. 1640.2(a)(2) as Sec. 1640.2(b) and
revising the language for clarity and readability. No substantive
changes were made to this subsection. LSC received no comments on this
proposal. LSC proposed redesignating existing Sec. 1640.2(b)(1) and
(2) as Sec. 1640.4(a) and (c) respectively.
Proposed Sec. 1640.3--Contractual Agreement
LSC proposed revising existing Sec. 1640.3 for clarity and
readability. No substantive changes were made to this subsection. LSC
received no comments on this proposal.
Proposed Sec. 1640.4--Violation of Agreement
LSC proposed redesignating existing Sec. 1640.2(b)(1) and (2) as
Sec. 1640.4(a) and (c) respectively. The proposed move groups each
definition in existing Sec. 1640.2(b) with each definition's
consequence for violating the agreement
[[Page 21656]]
in existing Sec. 1640.4. No substantive changes were made, but the
text has been revised for clarity and readability throughout the
section. LSC received no comments on this proposal.
List of Subjects in 45 CFR part 1640
Fraud; Grant programs--law; Legal services.
For the reasons stated in the preamble, the Legal Services
Corporation revises 45 CFR part 1640 to read as follows:
PART 1640--APPLICATION OF FEDERAL LAW TO LSC RECIPIENTS
Sec.
1640.1 Purpose.
1640.2 Applicable Federal laws.
1640.3 Contractual agreement.
1640.4 Violation of agreement.
Authority: 42 U.S.C. 2996e(g).
Sec. 1640.1 Purpose.
The purpose of this part is to ensure that recipients use their LSC
funds in accordance with Federal law related to the proper use of
Federal funds. This part also provides notice to recipients of the
consequences of a violation of such Federal laws by a recipient, its
employees or board members.
Sec. 1640.2 Applicable federal laws.
(a) LSC will maintain an exhaustive list of applicable Federal laws
relating to the proper use of Federal funds on its Web site and provide
recipients with a link to the list in the contractual agreement. The
list may be modified with the approval of the Corporation's Board of
Directors at a public meeting. LSC will provide recipients with notice
when the list is modified.
(b) For the purposes of this part and the laws referenced in
paragraph (a) of this section, LSC is considered a Federal agency and a
recipient's LSC funds are considered Federal funds provided by grant or
contract.
Sec. 1640.3 Contractual agreement.
As a condition of receiving LSC funds, a recipient must enter into
a written agreement with the Corporation that, with respect to its LSC
funds, will subject the recipient to the applicable Federal laws
relating to the proper use of Federal funds. The agreement must include
a statement that all of the recipient's employees and board members
have been informed of such Federal law and of the consequences of a
violation of such law, both to the recipient and to themselves as
individuals.
Sec. 1640.4 Violation of agreement.
(a) LSC will determine that a recipient has violated the agreement
described in Sec. 1640.3 when the recipient has been convicted of, or
judgment has been entered against the recipient for, a violation of an
applicable Federal law relating to the proper use of Federal funds with
respect to its LSC grant or contract, by the court having jurisdiction
of the matter, and any appeals of the conviction or judgment have been
exhausted or the time for appeal has expired.
(b) A violation of the agreement by a recipient based on recipient
conduct will result in the Corporation terminating the recipient's LSC
grant or contract without need for a termination hearing. While an
appeal of a conviction or judgment is pending, the Corporation may take
any necessary steps to safeguard its funds.
(c) LSC will determine that the recipient has violated the
agreement described in Sec. 1640.3 when an employee or board member of
the recipient has been convicted of, or judgment has been entered
against the employee or board member for, a violation of an applicable
Federal law relating to the proper use of Federal funds with respect to
the recipient's grant or contract with LSC, by the court having
jurisdiction of the matter, and any appeals of the conviction or
judgment have been exhausted or the time for appeal has expired, and
the Corporation finds that the recipient has knowingly or through gross
negligence allowed the employee or board member to engage in such
activities.
(d) A violation of the agreement by the recipient based on employee
or board member conduct will result in the Corporation terminating the
recipient's LSC grant or contract. Prior to termination, the
Corporation will provide notice and an opportunity to be heard for the
sole purpose of determining whether the recipient knowingly or through
gross negligence allowed the employee or board member to engage in the
activities leading to the conviction or judgment. While an appeal of a
conviction or judgment or a hearing is pending, the Corporation may
take any necessary steps to safeguard its funds.
Dated: April 15, 2015.
Stefanie K. Davis,
Assistant General Counsel.
[FR Doc. 2015-08974 Filed 4-17-15; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 7050-01-P