[Impeachment of President William Jefferson Clinton - The Evidentiary Record Pursuant to S. Res. 16 - Index to Senate Document 106-3, Vols. I-XXIV] [Volume VI - Votes of the Committee in Executive Session to H. Res. 525, Committee Print, Ser, No. 7, September 17, 18, 25, 1998] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office, www.gpo.gov] 106th Congress Document 1st Session SENATE 106-3 _______________________________________________________________________ IMPEACHMENT OF PRESIDENT WILLIAM JEFFERSON CLINTON __________ THE EVIDENTIARY RECORD PURSUANT TO S. RES. 16 VOLUME VI Votes of the Committee in Executive Session to H. Res. 525, Committee Print, Ser. No. 7, September 17, 18, 25, 1998 [GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TONGRESS.#13 Printed at the direction of Gary Sisco, Secretary of the Senate, pursuant to S. Res. 16, 106th Cong., 1st Sess. (1999) January 8, 1999.--Ordered to be printed 105th Congress Ser. No. 7 2d Session COMMITTEE PRINT _______________________________________________________________________ VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE IN EXECUTIVE SESSION PURSUANT TO H. RES. 525 __________ COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ONE HUNDRED FIFTH CONGRESS Henry J. Hyde, ChairmanSEPTEMBER 17, 18, 25, 1998 -------- U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 53-445 WASHINGTON : 1998 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ For sale by the U.S. Government Printing Office Superintendent of Documents, Congressional Sales Office, Washington, DC 20402 COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY HENRY J. HYDE, Illinois, Chairman F. JAMES SENSENBRENNER, Jr., JOHN CONYERS, Jr., Michigan Wisconsin BARNEY FRANK, Massachusetts BILL McCOLLUM, Florida CHARLES E. SCHUMER, New York GEORGE W. GEKAS, Pennsylvania HOWARD L. BERMAN, California HOWARD COBLE, North Carolina RICK BOUCHER, Virginia LAMAR SMITH, Texas JERROLD NADLER, New York ELTON GALLEGLY, California ROBERT C. SCOTT, Virginia CHARLES T. CANADY, Florida MELVIN L. WATT, North Carolina BOB INGLIS, South Carolina ZOE LOFGREN, California BOB GOODLATTE, Virginia SHEILA JACKSON LEE, Texas STEPHEN E. BUYER, Indiana MAXINE WATERS, California ED BRYANT, Tennessee MARTIN T. MEEHAN, Massachusetts STEVE CHABOT, Ohio WILLIAM D. DELAHUNT, Massachusetts BOB BARR, Georgia ROBERT WEXLER, Florida WILLIAM L. JENKINS, Tennessee STEVEN R. ROTHMAN, New Jersey ASA HUTCHINSON, Arkansas THOMAS BARRETT, Wisconsin EDWARD A. PEASE, Indiana CHRISTOPHER B. CANNON, Utah JAMES E. ROGAN, California LINDSEY O. GRAHAM, South Carolina MARY BONO, California Majority Staff Thomas E. Mooney, Sr., Chief of Staff-General Counsel Jon W. Dudas, Deputy General Counsel-Staff Director Diana L. Schacht, Deputy Staff Director-Chief Counsel Daniel M. Freeman, Parliamentarian-Counsel Paul J. McNulty, Director of Communications-Chief Counsel Joseph H. Gibson, Chief Counsel Rick Filkins, Counsel Sharee M. Freeman, Counsel Peter J. Levinson, Counsel John F. Mautz, IV, Counsel William E. Moschella, Counsel Stephen Pinkos, Counsel George M. Fishman, Chief Counsel David P. Schippers, Chief Mitch Glazier, Chief Counsel Investigative Counsel John H. Ladd, Chief Counsel Raymond V. Smietanka, Chief Counsel Susan Bogart, Investigative Laura Ann Baxter, Counsel Counsel Daniel J. Bryant, Counsel John C. Kocoras, Counsel Cathleen A. Cleaver, Counsel Berle S. Littmann, Investigator Vince Garlock, Counsel Charles F. Marino, Counsel James W. Harper, Counsel Jeffery J. Pavletic, Investigative Susan Jensen-Conklin, Counsel Counsel Debra K. Laman, Counsel Thomas M. Schippers, Investigative Blaine S. Merritt, Counsel Counsel Nicole R. Nason, Counsel Albert F. Tracy, Investigator Glenn R. Schmitt, Counsel Peter J. Wacks, Investigator Jim Y. Wilon, Counsel Diana L. Woznicki, Investigator Minority Staff Julian Epstein, Minority Chief Counsel-Staff Director Perry H. Apelbaum, Minority General Abbe D. Lowell, Minority Chief Counsel Investigative Counsel David G. Lachman, Counsel Sampak P. Garg, Investigative Cynthia A. R. Martin, Counsel Counsel Stephanie J. Peters, Counsel Steven F. Reich, Investigative Samara T. Ryder, Counsel Counsel Brian P. Woolfolk, Counsel Deborah L. Rhode, Investigative Counsel Kevin M. Simpson, Investigative Counsel Lis W. Wiehl, Investigative Counsel VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE IN EXECUTIVE SESSION PURSUANT TO H. RES. 525 ---------- SEPTEMBER 17, 18, AND 25, 1998 U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on the Judiciary, Washington, DC. Vote of the Committee September 17, 1998 subject Motion by Mr. Sensenbrenner to table Mr. Frank's motion. The motion was agreed to by a vote of 21 ayes to 15 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. X .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. .............. X .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 21 15 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Motion to table was orally made Mr Frank moves that the Committee go into public session to debate and vote on motions regarding the terms and timing of the release of information, during which debate and votes executive session rules will still apply to the actual information itself. Subject Amendment by Ms. Lofgren and Ms. Jackson-Lee to Hyde Motion #1. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 13 ayes to 21 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 13 21 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Ms. Lofgren and Jackson-Lee Ms. Lofgren and Jackson-Lee moves that all of the materials in volumes two through seven of the referral of the independent Counsel remain in executive session until such time as the Committee determines whether the allegations of impeachable conduct contained in the referral of the Independent Counsel could constitute an abuse of the official powers of the office of the President having a great impact upon the system of government as defined by Republican Ranking Member Hutchinson during the Committee consideration of the Watergate articles of impeachment. Subject Amendment by Ms. Lofgren to Hyde Motion #1. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 15 ayes to 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 3 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 15 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ms. Lofgren moves that the transcript of the Committee proceedings, up to the point this motion is made, be made public contemporaneous with the release of other materials which the Committee elects to release in the September 17, 1998 executive session meeting. Subject Amendment by Mr. Scott, as amended by unanimous consent, to Hyde Motion #1. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 14 ayes to 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 4 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 14 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Mr. Scott Mr. Scott moves that all of the materials in volumes two through seven of the referral of the Independent Counsel remain in executive session until September 28, 1998, so each member of the committee will have sufficient time to conduct a thorough and careful review of those materials. Barrett Amendment to the Scott Amendment adopted by O.C. Subject Amendment by Mr. Delahunt to Hyde Motion #1. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 13 ayes to 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 5 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 13 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Mr. Delahunt Mr. Delahunt moves that all of the materials in volumes two through seven of the referral of the Independent Counsel remain in executive session until such time that the counsel to the President has had a reasonable opportunity for full and fair review of all material held in executive session. Subject Amendment by Mr. Rotham to Hyde Motion #1. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 13 ayes to 19 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 13 19 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Mr. Rothman Mr. Rothman moves that any and all material voted to be released by the Committee at its executive session on September 17, 1998, be released to the public, simultaneous with any further release of materials authorized by the Committee pursuant to Section 2 of House Resolution 525, on September 28, 1998. Subject Amendment by Ms. Jackson-Lee to Hyde Motion #1. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 4 ayes to 28 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 7 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 4 28 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Ms. Jackson-Lee In the event that nay materials referred by the Independent Counsel to this House Judiciary Committee are released pursuant to House Resolution 525 during its executive session on September 17, 1998, the terms of that release shall be consistent with the commands of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which reads in pertinent part: ``No person shall be . . . deprived of life, liberty or property. . . . without due process of law . . . .'' Subject Amendment by Mr. Inglis to proposed redaction report. The amendment was defeated by a vote of 5 ayes, 29 nays, with one pass. ROLLCALL NO. 8 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. PASS Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. X .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. .............. X .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 5 29 1 PASS ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment Offered by Mr. Inglis The redaction report accompanying the material being considered for release by motion is amended on page 3 at column 3 referring to Volume IV, Tab 15, p. 20, lines 3-16 of the material, so that the ``reason for redaction'' reads ``description of oral-anal sexual contact between the President and Monica Lewinsky.'' Subject Amendment #1 by Mr. Barr to proposed redaction report. The Committee agreed not to redact the material by a vote of 16 ayes and 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 9 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 16 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment Offered by Mr. Barr The redaction report accompanying the material being considered for release by motion is amended at page 3, column 5, referring to Volume IV, Tab 15, p.37, line 25 of the material so that the material referenced therein is not redacted. Subject Amendment #2 by Mr. Barr to proposed redaction report. The Committee agreed not to redact the material by a vote of 16 ayes and 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 16 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment Offered by Mr. Barr The redaction report is further amended at page 3, column 6, referring to Volume IV, Tab 15, p. 38, line 1 and line 18 of the material so that the material referenced is not redacted. Subject Amendment #3 by Mr. Barr to proposed redaction report. The Committee agreed not to redact the material by a vote of 16 ayes and 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 11 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 16 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment Offered by Mr. Barr The redaction report is further amended at page 3, column 15, referring to volume IV, Tab 20, page, paragraph 1 of the material so that the material referenced is not redacted. Subject Amendment by Mr. Buyer to the proposed redaction report. The amendment was agreed to by a vote of 22 ayes to 14 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 12 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. X .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. .............. X .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 22 14 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment Offered by Mr. Barr The redaction report accompanying the material being considered for release by motion is amended at page 3, column 13, referring to Volume IV, Tab 20, p.9, lines 4-5 of the first full paragraph of the material so that the sentences ``They have phone sex, with LEWINSKY doing all the talking. LEWINSKY spoke all the words.'' are not redacted. VOICE VOTE The chair moved that the proposed redaction report be approved as amended. The motion was orally made. The Committee approved the motion on a voice vote. September 18, 1998 ROLLCALL NO. 1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 15 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Mr. Conyers Mr. Conyers moves to add the following redactions concerning inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters to the redaction log. Material marked as Conyers Amendment 1. VOICE VOTE Amendment by Mr. Conyers to Hyde Motion #1A. The Committee approved the motion on a voice vote. Amendment offered by Mr. Conyers to Hyde Motion #1A At the end of paragraph A, strike ``and''. In paragraph B, after the work ``Chairman'', add the words and the Ranking Minority Member''. At the end of paragraph B, strike the period and insert in lieu thereof ``;and''. Add a new paragraph C as follows: (C) the public printer is directed to deliver the House document, ready for distribution, simultaneously to the Chairman and the Ranking Minority Member. VOICE VOTE Amendment by Mr. Watt to Hyde Motion #1A. The Committee defeated the amendment on a voice vote. Motion #1A by Mr. Hyde Mr. Hyde moves that the Committee, pursuant to H. Res. 525-- a. deliver the materials in volumes two through seven of the referral of the Independent Counsel, with such redactions that have been approved by the Committee, (and of redaction log thereof), to the public printer for printing as a document of the House; and b. such document of the House shall be deemed released and publicly available at such time as the public printer advises the Chairman that the House document is ready for distribution Mr. Watt moves that the phrase in parenthesis be removed. Subject Motion #1A, as amended, by Mr. Hyde. The motion was agreed to by a vote of 20 ayes to 15 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. X .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. .............. X .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 20 15 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Motion #1A by Mr. Hyde as amended Mr. Hyde moves that the Committee, pursuant to H. Res. 525-- a. deliver the materials in volumes two through seven of the referral of the Independent Counsel, with such redactions that have been approved by the Committee, and a redaction log thereof, to the public printer for printing as a document of the House; b. such document of the House shall be deemed released and publicly available at such time as the public printer advises the Chairman and the Ranking Minority Members that the House document is ready for distribution; and c. the Public Printer is directed to deliver the House document, ready for distribution, simultaneously to the Chairman and the Ranking Minority Member. Subject Motion #2A by Mr. Hyde. Agreed to by a vote of 20 ayes to 15 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 3 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. X .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. .............. X .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 20 15 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Motion #2A by Mr. Hyde Mr. Hyde moves that the Committee, pursuant to H.Res 525-- (A) release the video tape of the President's grand jury testimony of August 17, 1998, and (B) that such video tape may be released and made publicly available at such time as the public printer advises the Chairman and the Ranking Minority Member that the House document printed pursuant to motion of the Committee on the Judiciary relating to the materials in volumes two through seven of the referral of the Independent Counsel is ready for distribution. Subject Motion by Mr. Scott. The motion was defeated by a vote of 15 ayes to 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 4 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 15 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Motion offered by Mr. Scott Mr. Scott moves that the transcript of the Committee proceedings, up to the point this motion is made, be made public contemporaneously with the release of other materials which the Committee elects to release from the September 17, 1998, and September 18, 1998 executive sessions. Subject Motion by Mr. Sensenbrenner. The motion was adopted by a vote of 28 ayes to 7 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 5 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 28 7 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Motion #3 by Mr. Sensenbrenner Mr. Sensenbrenner moves that, pursuant to H.Res 525, the votes of the Members during the executive session of the Committee on the Judiciary on September 17 and 18, 1998 be made public. September 25, 1998 Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to move to withhold from release to the public all personal identifying information, including addresses, telephone numbers, social security numbers, financial account information, and other personal identifying information, excluding names, contained in the materials to be released under H. Res. 525. Adopted by voice vote. SUBJECT Motion to table Mr. Frank's motion that the Committee meet in public session except for motions and debates which will require quotation from or descriptions of the specific contents of materials which the House has instructed to be treated as executive session material. Adopted by a vote of 19 ayes to 16 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ .............. X .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. .............. X .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 19 16 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to move to withhold from release to the public all information related to the national security of the United States, as identified in redaction logs, contained in the materials to be released under H. Res 525. Adopted by a vote of 36 ayes, 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 36 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to move to withhold from release to the public the names and other identifying information of all employees and persons affiliated with the Federal Bureau of Investigation, contained in the materials to be released under H. Res. 525, pursuant to a request by the Office of Independent counsel. Adopted by a vote of 36 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 3 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 36 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion offered by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to move to withhold from release to the public the reports of interviews (302s) of 2 individuals and grand jury testimony of 1 individual contained in the materials to be released under H. Res. 525, pursuant to a request by the office of Independent Counsel. Adopted by a vote of 36 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 4 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 36 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Frank to the Hyde/Conyers Motion to add the words ``including any videotape for which there is no written transcript'' at the end of the first sentence of the Hyde/ Conyers Motion #5. Adopted by a vote of 34 ayes to 2 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 5 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 34 2 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to move to withhold from public release the videotaped version of any testimony for which there exists no corresponding written transcript, including any videotape for which there is not written transcript. In addition, Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers move to withhold from public release the portions of any videotapes which correspond exactly to the redactions, if any, in the written transcripts of any such tapes. it is ordered that the accuracy of the redactions, if any, subject to this motion,be verified by majority and minority designated staff of the Committee before release to the public under H. Res 525. Adopted by a vote of 36 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 36 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to move to withhold from public release the videotaped version of any testimony for which there exists no corresponding written transcript, including any videotape for which there is no written transcript. In addition, Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers move to withhold from public release the portions of any videotapes which correspond exactly to the redactions, if any, in the written transcripts of any such tapes. It is ordered that the accuracy of the redactions, if any, subject to this motion, be verified by majority and minority designated staff of the Committee before release to the public under H. Res 525. Adopted by a vote of 36 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 6 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 36 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to withhold from release to the public confidential, private, unrelated and personal information concerning 7 individuals as identified in redaction logs, contained in the materials to be released under H. Res. 525, pursuant to the requests of those individuals. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 7 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to withhold at this time from release to the public information remaining under seal in the case of Jones v. Clinton, as identified in the attached redaction logs, contained in the materials to be released under H.Res 525. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 8 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to withhold from release to the public the information identified in redaction logs to accompany the materials to be released under H.Res 525. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 9 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to withhold from release to the public the portions of the audiotapes of Linda Tripp which correspond exactly to the redactions in the transcripts of such tapes approved by the Committee in the previous motion. The Chairman is authorized, after consulting the Ranking Minority Member, to obtain the services of a person with the technical competency to make such electronic redactions who shall make the redactions on the audiotapes and submit them to the Chairman. It is ordered that the accuracy of the redactions subject to this motion be verified by Chairman Hyde and Ranking minority member Conyers before release to the public under H. Res. 525. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Hyde and Mr. Conyers to withhold from release to the public complete items identified in redaction logs to accompany the materials to be release under H. Res. 525. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 11 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Nadler to redact inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters. Adopted by a vote of 33 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 12 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 33 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Nadler to redact inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 13 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Nadler to redact inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters. Adopted by a vote of 35 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 14 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 35 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Mr. Nadler Motion to redact inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters. Adopted by a vote of 23 ayes to 12 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 15 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 23 12 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Ms. Lofgren moved that consistent with standards and procedures utilized during the 1974 Watergate Impeachment inquiry by the committee,that all of the remaining materials that have been transmitted to Congress by the Office of the Independent Counsel remain in executive session until such time as the Committee determines whether the allegations of impeachable conduct contained in the referral of the Independent Counsel, if true, could constitute conduct subversive of our Constitutional system of governemnt with manifest injury to the people of the United States, to wit, a ``high crime and misdemeanor,'' as defined by the House of Representatives on august 20, 1974 by a vote of 402-3. Defeated by a vote of 13 ayes to 19 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 16 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 13 19 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Conyers for the Committee to make requests to the Independent Counsel. Defeated by a vote of 14 ayes to 19 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 17 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 14 19 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Motion #1 offered by Mr. Conyers Mr. Conyers moves that the Committee make the following requests of the Office of Independent Counsel: 1. To provide to the Committee all of the materials submitted to the United States Courts of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Division for the Purpose of Appointing Independent Counsels, including the ``Ex Parte Motion for approval of Disclosure of Matters Occurring Before a Grand Jury,'' in connection with the July 7, 1998 order issued by that division permitting ``disclosure of all grand jury material that the independent counsel deems necessary to comply with the requirements of 595(c).'' 2. To provide to the Committee all of the materials, including any notes and briefing presented or submitted to the Attorney general of the United States in support of the request for expanded jurisdiction that it received on January 16, 1998. In addition, the Committee requests that it be provided with a list of all OIC personnel who were present during the presentation to the Attorney General and/or her staff in support of the request for expanded jurisdiction. 3. To permit the members of the Committee on the Judiciary, along with designated staff, to inspect all other materials relating to the investigation conducted by the Office of Independent Counsel pursuant to the expanded jurisdiction granted it by the Attorney General of the United States on January 16, 1998. 4. To provide to the Committee all of the notes, and rought drafts generated by the OIC in connection with the interviews, depositions, and grand jury transcripts included in the referral submitted to Congress pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Sec. 595(c). SUBJECT Scott Motion to provide that all remaining materials transmitted by the Independent Counsel remain in executive session until such time as the President and any other individuals named in the information have had a reasonable opportunity for full and fair review of all materials pertaining to them held in executive session. Defeated by a vote of 14 ayes to 19 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 18 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 14 19 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Mr. Nadler motion to add further redactions concerning inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters to the redaction log. Agreed to by a vote of 34 ayes to 0 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 19 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... X .............. .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. X .............. .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. X .............. .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 34 0 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Mr. Nadler motion to add further redactions concerning inappropriate sexual and otherwise irrelevant matters to the redaction log. Agreed to by a vote of 17 ayes to 16 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 20 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 17 16 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Mr. Scott that all of the remaining materials that have been transmitted to Congress by the Office of Independent Counsel remain in executive session until such time as the counsel to the resident has had a reasonable opportunity for full and fair review of all material held in executive session. Defeated by a vote of 14 ayes to 19 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 21 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. .............. .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 14 19 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Mr. Delahunt Motion to provide that all of the witness testimony that has been transmitted to Congress by the Office of Independent Counsel remain in executive session until such time as the counsel for each witness has been given a reasonable opportunity to review the testimony of their clients and to offer any objections thereto before public release. Defeated 14 ayes to 20 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 22 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 14 20 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion #1 by Ms. Jackson Lee that all of the remaining materials that have been transmitted to Congress by the Independent counsel remain in executive session until the completion of the Committee's work. Defeated by a vote of 8 ayes to 27 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 23 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 8 27 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT Motion by Ms. Jackson Lee. Defeated by a vote of 15 ayes to 21 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 24 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 15 21 .............. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Amendment to Motion #1 offered by Ms. Jackson-Lee Ms. Jackson-Lee moves that any materials referred by the Independent Counsel to this House Judiciary Committee that are released pursuant to House Resolution 525 during its executive session on September 28, 1998, shall be released in accordance with existing House rules which incorporate and reflect the principles and protections of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which reads in pertinent part: No person shall be . . . deprived of life, liberty or property . . . without due process of law . . .'' SUBJECT Motion by Ms. Lofgren and Mr. Scott that the transcript of the debate in today's Committee meeting be made public after appropriate redactions have been made to remove any debate over material that continues to be held in executive session after September 28, 1998. Defeated by a vote of 17 ayes to 19 nays. ROLLCALL NO. 25 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Ayes Nays Present ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Sensenbrenner............................................... .............. X .............. Mr. McCollum.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Gekas....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Coble....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Smith (TX).................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Gallegly.................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Canady...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Inglis...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Goodlatte................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Buyer....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Bryant (TN)................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Chabot...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barr........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Jenkins..................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Hutchinson.................................................. .............. X .............. Mr. Pease....................................................... .............. .............. .............. Mr. Cannon...................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Rogan....................................................... .............. X .............. Mr. Graham...................................................... .............. X .............. Ms. Bono........................................................ .............. X .............. Mr. Conyers..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Frank....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Schumer..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Berman...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Boucher..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Nadler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Scott....................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Watt........................................................ X .............. .............. Ms. Lofgren..................................................... X .............. .............. Ms. Jackson Lee................................................. X .............. .............. Ms. Waters...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Meehan...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Delahunt.................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Wexler...................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Rothman..................................................... X .............. .............. Mr. Barrett (WI)................................................ X .............. .............. Mr. Hyde, Chairman.............................................. .............. X .............. ----------------------------------------------- Total....................................................... 17 19 .............. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------